3 Reasons Critiquing Will Improve Your Writing

This is a guest post by Audrey Chin. Audrey is a published author and poet from Singapore. Her novel, Learning to Fly, is currently available free on Story Cartel in exchange for your honest review. You can also follow her on her blog at audreychin.com. Thanks Audrey!

You’ve been told over and over that we writers must read to improve our craft. Over at the Story Cartel Course, we’ve been practicing critiquing. I’ve learned writers can’t  just read, we must critique!

Red Pen

Photo by the Italian Voice

There’s a quantum difference between the engaged reading needed before I can do a critique and my normal browsy-lazy-let’s- enjoy-myself-and-escape-to-a-different-place reading.

In the Story Cartel Course we’re asked to list three likes before we list our dislikes. As responsible members of a writing community we also need to suggest ways to improve on what we dislike. Now that’s hard work. It’s certainly helped to improve my writing practice.

Here are three reasons critiquing can improve your writing:

1. You Gain Perspective

Many of us have trouble sharing our stories. But once you’ve gotten over the hurdle of fear and vulnerability and worked and reworked your story, you think you’re entitled to be read. After all, haven’t you done your best work?

Critiquing other writer’s unformed drafts helped me understand that being read isn’t a right.  We become “readable” when we pay attention to “readability”. It’s a learning experience we can’t get reading Nobel prize-winning classics or our very own precious manuscript. It’s when we come to an “ah-hah!” moment after struggling through the first one-third of an unformed work, or start nodding off in the last third of something dense with poetic language that we realize the importance of  a good start, engaging characters and proper pacing. It’s only then we learn to look for these hurdles in our own work.

2. You Value The Second and Third and Fourth Drafts

I’m a slow writer, editing and revising as I go along. Once I’m done, I send my stuff out to my reading group. After that, it’s one big revision and one grammar and spell check, and then it’s out the door with the story. Perfect enough, I thought. Critiquing—and reading other people’s critiques—has shown me that there are many ways to tell and re-tell a story.

There are some really talented writers in the Story Cartel Course. They’re willing to do the work; not only a second or third time but a fourth. I’ve seen how their stories morphed from good to great. It’s given me an appreciation for the fourth draft!

3. You Appreciate Stories That Connect Emotionally

The story that makes the emotional connection always carries the reader through to the end, no matter how many stutters and stumbles it has.

I’m a cerebral person, someone who’s moved by the beauty of the words.

Critiquing has taught me that the best stories are still the ones that move hearts. And what moves heart is simple honest vulnerability.

How about you? What have you learned about writing from critiquing? 


In this practice, pick a practice from yesterday’s post. Comment on the piece with three reasons why you like the piece and then three ways it can be improved.  Then, if you haven’t written a practice of your own, write one and post it in yesterday’s comments section.

Have fun and watch your own work improve.

About Joe Bunting

Joe Bunting is a writer and entrepreneur. He is the author of the #1 Amazon Bestseller Let's Write a Short Story! and the co-founder of Story Cartel. You can follow him on Twitter (@joebunting).

  • Mirelba

    Good post, Audrey. Very true. And I think that another thing we learn from critiquing is the importance of community. By working together, we help others be their best, and are helped by others in turn.

    In addition, by paying attention to what it is that we like, we find ways to improve our own writing.

    • Audrey Chin

      Indeed Mirel. What would we do without the support, encouragement and honest feedback of a like minded community?

  • I Agree

  • Each time I critique someone I am being reminded of the very things that make good writing. The act of critiquing just reinforces what we need to do ourselves.

    I do agree with you about the best stories being those which move hearts.

  • Shelley

    I also like the beauty of words. With each draft, we get closer and closer to our goal. Having someone critique our work informs us of our effectiveness, or lack thereof. The eyes of others reveal what we often are blind to.

    • Audrey Chin

      Love the words “the eyes of others reveal what we often are blind to.” Thanks Shelley

  • Very impressive article. I am glad to catch idea from your article.

  • Thanks Audrey I agree with everything you mentioned, for me I learn structure and flow for my own work and how to be creatively helpful to someone else. Also the connection and respect for the writer that I have critiqued.

  • Stephanie Noel

    Thank you for the information about the Story Cartel Course. It looks very interesting!

  • I can’t categorical my thanks enough for the attention-grabbing points you have got created during this article.

  • I consider plenty of this content. thanks for inscribing this partaking and intelligent article.

  • If I were the one having to jot down this content, of these readers would be frustrated. it is a smart factor you’re the author and you bring recent concepts to U.S.A. all. this can be attention-grabbing.

  • After browsing internet for associate hour i accustomed be very happy to hunt out this text.

  • Thanks for sharing.It is very helpful for me

  • Thank you for the information about the Story Cartel Course.

  • every time I write, and read again, feeling it was stupid. I love writing my own pieces, but is difficult to be satisfied